Spotlight has to be one of the most unused technologies on my computer. Its not that I don’t need it — I need to search for things all the time. Its not that the idea behind Spotlight isn’t sound, it is. It makes a lot of sense to index files and make them available for a quick search.
The problem is it doesn’t work.
First, its slower than Christmas in Tehran on my machine. I’m not talking about the “indexing” time that I see a lot of people complaining about. I actually rarely see it indexing. However, on the off chance I try to do a search, it brings my machine to its knees, and its a Dual 2 Ghz G5 with a gig of RAM. The Finder locks up until the search is done and sometimes the disk activity it generates is so intense my whole machine locks up temporarily. I would assume its just this machine, but it happens on my PowerBook and my iMac/Intel as well.
I don’t get it. It always works for Steve.
And Lord help you if you use that stupid widget in the top right of your screen. Good grief. You’d better hope that the ten results it happens to show there are what you’re looking for (and they’re not), otherwise you have to open a real Spotlight window to get all the results. That means Spotlight has to run the entire query all over again, disk thrashing and all. Its the model of efficiency, that Spotlight.
The other thing that’s wrong with search in general is it just tells you that your search term is somewhere in a given file. There ought to be a way to then double click on the search result and have the application open up to where the search result is. But perhaps that’s just a distant dream.
Of course, the only reason I even tried Spotlight is because Xcode search sucks so badly. It only wants to search the current project, and even then only the files in the actual project (not included files). Sure, Apple has added all kinds of options to the Find dialog, and maybe one day they’ll add one that makes it useful. Until then, searching an arbitrary folder is one of the most painful experiences within Xcode (and there are a lot). Here’s what you have to do in Xcode:
- Command-Shift-F to open the Find in Files dialog.
- Press the “Options” button to get the Find Options dialog. (Why are these in a separate dialog?!?)
- So you don’t overwrite one of Apple’s precious predefined sets, press the “Add” button.
- Type in a name for your set and hit enter.
- Press the + button at the bottom and add the folder you want to search. (Also remove any left over folders from previous sets you don’t want.)
- Check the “Search in files and folders” box. (Why do I have check this? I just added a folder, isn’t it obvious what I want to do??)
- Uncheck “Search in open documents” and “Search in open projects.”
- Close the Find Options dialog and/or go back the Find dialog.
- Select your new Find set from the set popup.
- Type in the search term(s) you want to find, and press return.
Yes, in those short ten steps, you too can search for something in an arbitrary folder!
The problem is these stupid find sets that I have to create are there to increase flexibility. Undoubtedly, the engineer who created that whole mess thought “Think of the power and flexibility I’m giving the user! They can search for anything in any way they want! Having them save find sets means all the find options are nicely encapsulated!” But the problem is I don’t want flexibility, I want speed. And I don’t mean raw search speed, I mean speed of entering in my search criteria and having Xcode find it. When I’m looking for something, I’m in a hurry. I don’t have time to create one of your stupid Find sets, as architecturally nice as they might be. I’m sorry, ten steps to do anything is too many.
At the very least Apple should merge all the options into the Find dialog. And don’t force me to create a stupid find set. They could also add a default set that searches $SRC_ROOT.
The truth is I still keep CodeWarrior around, just so I can use its Find in Files dialog. It has a nice popup of all the previously searched in folders, or text field I can type the path into, or a browse button which I can use to go select the folder I want, all from the Find dialog. Apple, if you want to know how to make a decent search, look no further than CodeWarrior.
I hate searching on my Mac. Granted, I don’t have a dog asking me retarded questions, but its always a painful ordeal. It doesn’t have to be. The technology is there, but they need to run it through some usability specialists or at least a couple of real users.